1. Home
  2. Mattress Brands

Find the Best Mattresses in Buffalo, NY

No matter how you prefer to shop for a new mattress, there are a variety of mattress retailers for you to choose from in Western New York. The Buffalo News has partnered with ConsumerAffairs to create this guide by comparing the product selections and local popularity of 48 businesses and choosing nine favorites from the best mattress companies in Buffalo.

Companies pay ConsumerAffairs to be authorized, and The Buffalo News and/or ConsumerAffairs may receive compensation when you click a link, call a number or fill out a form on this site.

Compare Buffalo Mattress Stores and Brands

Types of mattresses in Buffalo

buffalo skyline

Whether you’re getting a mattress in a box delivered to your door or going to a local mattress store, there’s a lot to consider before buying a new mattress. One of the more significant factors you have to think about is the type of mattress you want.

Different types of mattresses are better for different types of sleepers:

  • Innerspring mattresses use metal coils to support your body weight and hold your spine in alignment during use. These mattresses are good if you prefer a traditional feel.
  • Latex mattresses combine latex foam with either springs or reflex foam to provide pressure relief. These mattresses are good for combination sleepers who change positions a lot.
  • Memory foam mattresses are made from polyurethane foams that conform to your body. These mattresses are good for any type of sleeper, including combination sleepers, but they cause some people to overheat.
  • Gel-infused foam mattresses take memory foam and combine it with cooling gel materials. This helps your regulate your body temperatures and stay cool. These mattresses are good for side sleepers.
  • Hybrid mattresses include a combination of memory foam, latex, gel or innersprings. These mattresses can last from seven to 10 years, depending on their least durable components. Hybrid mattresses are good for combination sleepers.

Once you know what kind of mattress you want, you can begin to shop around for the right model. However, there are still more decisions for you to make.

Buffalo mattress stores and mattress-in-a-box companies

There are different ways you can shop for a mattress, including through an online retailer or at a brick-and-mortar mattress store. Online companies are growing in popularity because of the convenience of shopping from home, but they can’t provide certain services, like letting you try out a mattress before you buy. Physical stores allow you to test a mattress out, but you may have to deal with limited availability and high-pressure sales tactics.

Online In-store
  • Convenient
  • Often cheaper
  • Generous trial periods
  • Try before buying
  • Get help choosing a mattress
  • Mattress disposal available
  • Haul-away service limited
  • Can’t try before buying
  • High-pressure sales tactics
  • Limited options

Buffalo mattress prices

In Buffalo, the cost of a mattress usually ranges from $600 to $2,500, but mattress prices depend on several factors, including the type and size you choose. If you want a more functional estimate, it helps to be more specific about what you’re looking for.

Here’s what different types of queen-size mattresses cost in Buffalo:

  • Innerspring mattress: $700 to $1,200
  • Memory foam mattress: $600 to $1,200
  • Latex mattress: $1,500 to $2,500
  • Hybrid mattress: $1,200 to $2,000

Many online and in person retailers offer seasonal sales and promotions throughout the year. So, if your chosen mattress is currently beyond your budget, consider waiting for a deal. If you still can’t afford the model you want, many companies offer financing to qualified buyers.

Buffalo mattress stores FAQ

How do I dispose of my mattress in Buffalo?

The Buffalo Department of Sanitation has a bulk trash pickup day that you can use to dispose of old mattresses. You may also be able to recycle your old mattress or pay to have a company come pick it up and dispose of it.

How much is a king-sized mattress in Buffalo?

King-sized mattresses range in price from $1,400 to over $5,000 in Buffalo, depending on the type of mattress you choose.

Which mattress is good for side sleepers?

Generally, foam or hybrid mattresses are a good choice for side sleepers because they relieve pressure on users’ shoulders and hips.

When is the best time to buy a mattress in Buffalo?

Typically, late winter and early spring are a buyers market for mattresses because retailers are making room for new models. Holidays are also a good time to buy because many retailers offer discounts over those weekends.

How much should I spend on a mattress in Buffalo?

Mattress prices vary significantly, but consumers can typically find a quality mattress for around $1,000. This ensures you aren’t sacrificing quality and comfort for cost.

Buffalo mattress company information


Saatva is a mattress manufacturer and retailer that sells hybrid innerspring mattresses with five layers. There are three levels of firmness available, and sizes range from twin to California king. The company also offers adjustable bases, foundations and frames. Saatva provides free delivery and a 180-night at-home trial.

Saatva Shop Now


PlushBeds is an online mattress retailer that sells its own brand of mattresses. These include natural and organic memory foam, sofa bed and RV mattresses. More specifically, its available mattress types include natural latex, hybrid latex, gel foam and memory foam. Sizes range from twin to split king (two pieces). Plushbeds also offers mattress toppers, pillows, headboards, footboards, adjustable bases and bedding. It provides a 25-year warranty on mattresses, free delivery and returns, and a 100-night free trial period.



Puffy is an online mattress retailer that only sells its own mattresses. The company offers three different types of mattresses that vary in thickness. All three types are hypoallergenic and stain-resistant. Sizes range from twin to California king. All mattresses come with a 101-night trial period, a lifetime warranty and free shipping.

Puffy Shop Now


Nectar is a mattress retailer that exclusively sells its own mattresses. The mattress types it offers include memory foam and hybrid mattresses. Sizes range from twin to California king, and all mattress purchases include pillows, sheets and mattress protectors for free. Nectar offers a 365-night trial period, free shipping and a lifetime warranty.

Nectar Shop Now


Casper sells its mattresses online and in select stores. It offers mattresses in three models: two hybrid mattresses and an all-foam mattress. Sizes range from twin to California king, and other available products include adjustable bases, pillows, bedding and bed frames. Casper has a 100-night trial period and a 10-year limited warranty.

Casper Shop Now


Avocado is an online mattress retailer offering organic hybrid, latex and vegan mattresses. Sizes range from crib to California king. In addition to mattresses, you can purchase toppers, bases, pillows, frames and protectors from this brand. Avocado offers a one-year trial, free shipping and a 25-year warranty.


Metro Mattress

Metro Mattress is a mattress company that sells products from several brands, including Sealy, Nectar, Spring Air and Tempur-Pedic. Sizes range from twin to California king. Metro Mattress offers a 30-day exchange guarantee. It’s located at 2625 Delaware Ave., Buffalo, NY 14216.

Metro Mattress


Macy’s is a department store chain selling mattresses from a variety of brands, including Sealy, Serta, Purple, Stearns & Foster and Beautyrest. It offers innerspring, memory foam, hybrid, and gel memory foam models. Sizes range from twin to California king. Related products include bedding, pillows, adjustable bases, box springs, headboards and footboards. Macy’s offers various returns and exchange options. The Buffalo Macy’s mattress gallery is located at 4 Walden Galleria, Buffalo, NY 14225.


Lake Effect Furniture and Mattress

Lake Effect Furniture and Mattress is an in-store mattress retailer that sells products from a variety of brands, including Ashley, Malouf, Corsicana and Restonic. It offers isolated coil, memory foam, foam and gel foam mattresses. Sizes range from twin to California king. Lake Effect Furniture and Mattress is located at 3637 Union Road, Cheektowaga, NY 14225.

Lake Effect Furniture and Mattress